loading

Boy Building a House of Cards

(Le faiseur de châteaux de cartes)

Artist or maker:
Chardin, Jean-Siméon (b.1699, d.1779)
Date:
1735
dated stylistically and by exhibition evidence
Place of production:
Paris, France
Medium:
oil on canvas
Type of object:
paintings
Accession number:
82.2007

Commentary

A child playing – with cards, bubbles, spinning-top or shuttlecock – was a favourite subject of Chardin. Such scenes were derived from 17th-century Netherlandish vanitas works, which bore messages about the transitory nature of human life and the worthlessness of material ambitions, but Chardin’s also display a delight in the ephemeral phases of childhood for their own sake.

In this intimate, but monumental painting, the fragile paper edifice embodies the fleeting nature of childhood; the cards the role of chance. The prominent ace of hearts might represent the precariousness of love. The jack in the drawer hints at rascalry. The boy’s apron suggests he may be a servant who should be clearing up after a gaming party.

Chardin depicted a young adolescent building a house of cards on at least four occasions. His other versions of the subject are in the National Gallery of Art, Washington (c. 1735), the Musée du Louvre, Paris (c. 1737) and the National Gallery, London (c. 1737). The Waddesdon painting has a more elaborate setting than these. The red curtain with its golden tassel adds a note of opulence. A screen is just visible on the right of the boy; the artist painted it out, but it has become visible again over time. Against the strong verticals and horizontals of the wall, cord, table and card house, the viewer’s attention is caught by the invisible diagonal linking the boy’s eye to the card that he is trying to balance with his right hand.

This was probably one of the paintings that Chardin showed to his colleagues at the Académie Royale de Peinture et de Sculpture in 1735, when he put his name forward for an academic position. It was almost certainly shown at the Paris Salon of 1737. Prints after the painting were made soon after its creation. An engraving by Pierre Fillœuil amplified its moralising note with a little verse about how old men should not mock the young since their schemes can be just as insubstantial. A series of etchings by Antoine Marcenay de Ghuy drew out the Rembrandtesque melancholy that several contemporary viewers found in Chardin’s genre paintings.

Juliet Carey, 2012

Physical description

Dimensions (mm):
810 x 1010
794 x 999 - sight
Signature & date:
signed, centre right: J. B. Chardin

History

Provenance:
Acquired by Victor Amadeus, Prince of Carignan (b.1690, d.1741) in Paris; inherited by his wife Maria Vittoria Francesca of Savoy, Princess of Carignan (b.1690, d.1766); sold in the sale of the Carignan and Mazarin collections, Prestage's, London, 26 February 1765, lot 37 for £6 to Robinson; acquired by William Fauquier (b.Circa 1700, d.1788); sold at the sale of the Fauquier collection, Christie's London, 30 January 1789, lot 75 for £5.15s to Stevens; acquired by George Simon, 2nd Earl Harcourt (b.1736, d.1809) before 1797 when in the Eating Room at Nuneham-Courtenay, Oxford; by descent through the Harcourt and Vernon-Harcourt families to William Edward, 2nd Viscount Harcourt (b.1908, d.1979) who took it to Stanton Harcourt, Oxford, in 1948; acquired by a Rothschild Family Trust in 2007.
Exhibition history:
Possibly Académie Royale, Paris, 1735, as 'Jeune Garçon jouant avec des cartes'

'French Art of the Eighteenth Century', Burlington Fine Arts Club, London, 1913, no. 8

'The Treasure Houses of Britain: Five Hundred Years of Private Patronage and Art Collecting', National Gallery of Art, Washington, 1985, no. 152

'Hidden Treasures: works of art from Oxfordshire private collections', Ashmolean Museum, Oxford, 27 July-17 October 1993, no. 11

'Boucher and Chardin: Masters of Modern Manners', Wallace Collection, London, 12 June - 7 September 2008; Hunterian Museum and Art Gallery, Glasgow, 24 September - 13 December 2008, no. 26.

'Taking Time: Chardin's Boy building a House of Cards and other paintings' Waddesdon Manor, 28 March to 15 July 2012
Collection:
Waddesdon (Rothschild Foundation)
On loan since 2007

Bibliography

Bibliography

Description of Nuneham-Courtenay, in the county of Oxford; Oxford; [n. pub.]; 1806; p. 18.
French art of the eighteenth century (a catalogue); Burlington Fine Arts Club, London, 1913; London; Burlington Fine Arts Club; 1914; pp. 21-22, no. 8, fig. 43.
André de Ridder; J.B.S. Chardin; Paris; Librairie Floury; 1932; pl. 61.
Daniel Wildenstein; Chardin; Paris; Les Beaux Arts; 1933; pp. 167-168, no. 143, fig. 209; as doubtable.
Daniel Wildenstein; Chardin; Connecticut; New York Graphic Society; 1969; p. 172, no. 146, fig. 64; as whereabouts unknown.
David Carritt, Mr Fauquier's Chardins, The Burlington Magazine, 116, 1974, 502-09; figs 1-2; dated on stylistic and exhibition evidence grounds to 1735.
Pierre Rosenberg; Tout L'oeuvre peint de Chardin; Paris; Flammarion; 1983; pp. 92-93, no. 102, ill.
Catherine Whistler; Hidden treasures: works of art from Oxfordshire private collections; Ashmolean Museum, Oxford, 27 July-17 October 1993; Oxford; Ashmolean Museum; 1993; p. 14, no. 11.
Pierre Rosenberg; Chardin; Galeries nationales du Grand Palais, Paris, 7 September -22 November 1999; Kunstmuseum et Kunsthalle, Düsseldorf, 5 December 1999 - 20 February 2000; Royal Academy of Arts, London, 9 March - 28 May 2000; Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, 19 June -17 September 2000; Paris; Réunion des musées nationaux; 1999; pp. 216, 218.
Katie Scott; Chardin multiplé; Pierre Rosenberg, Chardin, Paris, Galeries nationales du Grand Palais, Paris, 7 September -22 November 1999; Kunstmuseum et Kunsthalle, Düsseldorf, 5 December 1999 - 20 February 2000; Royal Academy of Arts, London, 9 March - 28 May 2000; Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York, 19 June -17 September 2000, Réunion des musées nationaux, 1999; pp. 66-67.
Anne Dulau; Boucher & Chardin: Masters of Modern Manners; Wallace Collection, London, exh cat; Boucher & Chardin: Masters of Modern Manners; 12 June - 7 September 2008, (Hunterian Art Gallery, University of Glasgow, 24 September - 13 December 2008).; London; The Hunterian, University of Glasgow, Paul Holberton Publishing; 2008; pp. 102-103, cat. no. 26, ill.
Christoph Martin Vogtherr; New Beginnings in French Genre Painting: de Troy, Chardin, Boucher; Anne Dulau, Boucher & Chardin: Masters of Modern Manners, London, Wallace Collection, London, exh cat; Boucher & Chardin: Masters of Modern Manners; 12 June - 7 September 2008, (Hunterian Art Gallery, University of Glasgow, 24 September - 13 December 2008)., The Hunterian, University of Glasgow, Paul Holberton Publishing, 2008; p. 33, fig. 24.
Juliet Carey, New Paintings at Waddesdon Manor, Apollo, 168, September 2008, 52-57; pp. 56-57, fig. 9.

Indexed terms